Compare Car Insurance Quotes

Get great auto insurance coverage at an even better price

image icon of shield Free quotes, secure form, no spam.

Compare auto insurance rates and quotes at a glance

by Rob Bhatt and co-authored by Bryan Ochalla

Key takeaways

  • State Farm, USAA and Erie Insurance generally offer the lowest rates on car insurance.
  • USAA is only available to the military community and Erie is only available in 12 states plus the District of Columbia.
  • Your location, age, driving record and credit history have significant impacts on your car insurance rates.
  • Switching car insurance companies could save you up to 30% or more on premiums, depending on your situation.
  • Comparing car insurance quotes online is the most convenient way to shop.

Comparing multiple auto insurance quotes is the best way to make sure you’re not paying too much for car insurance. After all, the factors that determine your insurance rates, including your age, location, driving record and credit, often change, and so do the formulas that insurance companies use to calculate your premiums. Fortunately, it’s easy to save money by comparing quotes–online, by phone, in person, or through a combination of these channels.

As you prepare to shop, here’s what you need to know about how insurance companies set your rates and essential tips for comparing car insurance quotes.

In this article

Compare auto insurance rates by location

Location is one of the most significant factors insurance companies use to set premiums, because your rates reflect their costs of doing business in your community.

Cost of minimum coverage per state

Since car insurance requirements and regulations vary by state, you can expect to see major fluctuations in car insurance rates from state to state. Rates can also vary widely within different communities in the same state. For example, car insurance is about 25% cheaper in Peoria, Illinois, than it is in Chicago.

This is why it’s good to compare auto insurance rates from multiple companies when you move. Even if one company is giving you the lowest rate at your current address, a different company may be able to offer you a better deal at your new home.

Here's a look at the cheapest car insurance companies in each state.

Note: Rates shown in all tables are for full-coverage car insurance policies.

Car insurance rates by state
State Cheapest Insurer Average annual rate
Alabama State Farm $1,065
Alaska State Farm $971
Arizona Progressive $1,769
Arkansas State Farm $1,117
California GEICO $1,594
Colorado State Farm $1,280
Connecticut State Farm $1,491
Delaware State Farm $1,513
Florida GEICO $1,729
Georgia Georgia Farm Bureau $1,409
Hawaii GEICO $610
Idaho State Farm $703
Illinois State Farm $1,320
Indiana State Farm $930
Iowa State Farm $822
Kansas State Farm $1,074
Kentucky Kentucky Farm Bureau $2,097
Louisiana Louisiana Farm Bureau $1,232
Maine State Farm $762
Maryland Erie $1,370
Massachusetts Safety $1,266
Michigan Progressive $2,428
Minnesota State Farm $1,097
Mississippi Mississippi Farm Bureau $1,402
Missouri State Farm $1,105
Montana Progressive $951
Nebraska American Family $1,229
Nevada State Farm $1,556
New Hampshire State Farm $770
New Jersey State Farm $2,010
New Mexico State Farm $987
New York New York Central Mutual Fire $2,539
North Carolina North Carolina Farm Bureau $787
North Dakota American Family $966
Ohio Erie $926
Oklahoma Progressive $1,559
Oregon State Farm $1,144
Pennsylvania Erie $1,437
Rhode Island Progressive $3,492
South Carolina State Farm $1,347
South Dakota State Farm $952
Tennessee State Farm $1,005
Texas State Farm $2,463
Utah State Farm $1,275
Vermont State Farm $753
Virginia Virginia Farm Bureau $898
Washington Progressive $1,575
Washington DC Erie $1,272
West Virginia State Farm $949
Wisconsin American Family $996
Wyoming State Farm $992
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 35-year-old male with a good driving record

Compare Auto Insurance Rates

See how much you could save with a new policy

Compare auto insurance rates by age

Your age may just be a number to you, but to the insurance company, it’s one of the most important factors in determining how much you pay for car insurance, particularly if you are a teen or senior citizen.

Teen drivers can see car insurance rates that are more than double the amount charged to 25-year-olds. Middle-aged drivers tend to qualify for the lowest rates, but prices inch back up for drivers in their retirement years.

 

Car insurance rates for teen drivers

Teens have the highest crash rates among all age groups, and this is one of the main reasons why auto insurance companies charge teen drivers high rates for car insurance.

For example, a typical 25-year-old is charged 62% less for car insurance than a typical 18-year-old.

 

Teens typically get lower car insurance rates when they are added to a policy with a parent or a guardian than they do on their own.

If you plan to add the new teen driver in your family to your car insurance policy, make sure to compare rates from multiple companies and see if they offer discounts. Many car insurance companies offer discounts to families with teens who maintain good grades and/or complete an approved driver education course.

USAA, Mercury and Erie offer the cheapest car insurance to 18-year-old drivers. However, USAA is only available to current and former members of the military and their families. Erie is available in 12 states (plus the District of Columbia) and Mercury in 11 states.

Among national carriers, State Farm, American Family and GEICO are cheapest for 18-year-olds.

Cheapest car insurance companies for 18-year-olds
Company Average annual rate
Erie $2,695
USAA $3,460
Mercury $4,802
State Farm $5,000
American Family $5,347
GEICO $6,769
Allstate $7,242
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for an 18-year-old male with a good driving record.

Car insurance rates for adult drivers

Although 25-year-olds qualify for considerably lower car insurance rates than young drivers, prices level off in earnest for drivers between the ages of 30 and 60.

For example, 30-year-olds pay 11% less for car insurance than 25-year-olds. Insurance rates get progressively lower with each year of age for drivers between 30 and 60 years old, but a 60-year-old only pays $108 less per year than a 30-year-old.

Adults between 30 and 60 pay the lowest rates for car insurance, because they are generally considered the safest age group.

Erie, USAA and State Farm offer the cheapest car insurance to typical adults with a clean record.

Among the most widely available car insurers, the difference between the cheapest company, State Farm, and fifth-cheapest, Allstate, is 30%. This is one example of how much you may save by comparing car insurance rates from multiple companies when you shop.

Car insurance rates for a typical adult driver
Company Average annual rate
Erie $1,200
USAA $1,352
State Farm $1,712
American Family $1,776
Mercury $1,972
Progressive $2,031
GEICO $2,387
Allstate $2,433
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 35-year-old male with a good driving record.

Car insurance rates for senior drivers

Among age groups, senior citizens have slightly higher crash rates than middle-aged drivers, and this is one of the main reasons why those in their retirement years see higher insurance rates.

A typical driver qualifies for the lowest rates on car insurance at age 60. A 65-year-old driver only pays 2% more for car insurance than a 60-year-old, but a 75-year-old pays 22% more than a 60-year-old.

 

American Family, State Farm and Progressive are among the major national carriers with the lowest rates for senior citizen drivers, based on rates available to a typical 65-year-old.

Cheapest insurance companies for 65-year-old drivers
Company Average annual rate
Erie $1,141
USAA $1,381
American Family $1,520
State Farm $1,535
Progressive $1,862
Mercury $1,972
GEICO $2,159
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 65-year-old male with a good driving record

Compare auto insurance rates with prior incident

An accident, driving under the influence (DUI) or a speeding ticket typically increases your insurance rate, because insurance companies view those with prior incidents as riskier to insure.

The amount that insurance rates can rise after a traffic violation or accident range from 20% for a speeding ticket to 74% for a DUI.

Insurance rates for drivers with prior incidents
Incident Average annual rate Rate increase with incident
Clean record $2,136 No prior incidents
Accident $3,087 +45%
DUI $3,719 +74%
Speeding ticket $2,560 +20%
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 35-year-old male.

Most insurance companies add a surcharge to your rates for three to five years after a ticket or accident, but certain severe offenses may affect your rate for a longer period.

Bulb icon

If your current company is surcharging you for an incident that occurred more than three years ago, consider shopping around for a company with a shorter look-back period.

Car insurance rates after an at-fault accident

Erie, USAA and State Farm offer the cheapest car insurance rates to drivers after an at-fault accident.

State Farm only charges drivers with a prior accident 20% more than drivers with a clean record, while Mercury increases rates for drivers with an accident by 74%.

Company Average annual rate Rate increase with accident
Erie $1,519 +27%
USAA $2,007 +48%
State Farm $2,029 +19%
American Family $2,846 +60%
Progressive $3,231 +59%
Nationwide $3,326 +36%
Mercury $3,435 +74%
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 35-year-old male with an at-fault accident on his driving record.

Car insurance rates after a DUI/DWI conviction

Erie, State Farm and USAA offer the cheapest car insurance rates to drivers with a prior DUI, which is known in some states as driving while intoxicated/impaired (DWI) or operating while intoxicated/impaired (OWI).

Erie’s rates for a driver with a prior DUI are 72% higher than those for a driver with a clean record, while USAA increases rates for drivers with a DUI by 89%.

Insurance rates for drivers with a DUI
Company Average annual rate Rate increase with DUI
Erie $2,066 +72%
State Farm $2,390 +40%
USAA $2,562 +89%
Progressive $2,585 +27%
American Family $2,619 +47%
Mercury $3,263 +65%
Allstate $3,585 +47%
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 35-year-old male with a DUI on his driving record.

Car insurance rates after a speeding ticket

Erie, USAA and State Farm also offer the cheapest rates to drivers with a speeding ticket.

State Farm only charges 8% more to drivers with a speeding ticket. Mercury and Progressive each increase their rates on drivers with a speeding ticket by 32%.

Insurance rates for drivers with a speeding ticket
Company Average annual rate Rate increase with ticket
Erie $1,306 +9%
USAA $1,625 +20%
State Farm $1,846 +8%
American Family $2,053 +16%
Mercury $2,609 +32%
Progressive $2,679 +32%
GEICO $2,878 +21%
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 35-year-old male with a speeding ticket on his driving record.

Compare auto insurance rates by gender

Gender has a bigger impact on insurance rates for teen drivers than it does for those in their 30s or later.

For example, the average rate insurance companies charge to 18-year-old women is 17% less than the rate available for 18-year-old men. At age 35, men only pay about 1% more than women.

Average car insurance rates by gender
Age Average annual rate: women Average annual rate: men Price difference: women vs. men
18 $6,278 $7,555 -17%
35 $2,237 $2,254 -0.8%
55 $1,985 $2,001 -0.8%
Rates are for full-coverage policies for male and female drivers with good driving records.

Young women are generally viewed by insurance companies as safer drivers than young men and less likely to be involved in severe car accidents. This, in turn, makes young women cheaper to insure.

Car insurance rates by gender for 18-year-olds
Company Average annual rate: women Average annual rate: men Price difference: women vs. men
Allstate $5,909 $7,242 -18%
American Family $4,242 $5,347 -21%
Farmers $8,485 $8,405 +1%
GEICO $5,624 $6,769 -17%
Nationwide $6,866 $9,092 -24%
Progressive $7,702 $8,913 -14%
State Farm $3,879 $5,000 -22%
Travelers $10,845 $13,770 -21%
USAA $2,946 $3,460 -15%
Average $6,278 $7,555 -17%
Rates are for full-coverage policies for 18-year-old male and female drivers with good driving records.

Even though the differences between insurance rates for men and women are smaller for older age groups, gender alone may account for a portion of any price differences you may see as you compare car insurance quotes when you’re in your mid-30s or older.

For example, with all other factors for 35-year-old drivers being equal, Progressive charges men 5% less for car insurance than women. GEICO’s rates for a 35-year-old woman are 4% less than those for a 35-year-old man.

Compare auto insurance rates by credit score

Your credit history may have a bigger impact than you think on your car insurance rates, unless you live in one of the five states that prohibit insurance companies from using credit as a car insurance rate factor.

On average, drivers with good credit pay 44% less for auto insurance than those with poor credit, although credit-scoring practices vary by state and insurance company.

California, Hawaii, Maryland, Massachusetts and Michigan ban or limit credit-scoring for insurance rates.

In states where the practice is allowed, the credit reports insurance companies use typically focus on the amount and type of debt you have and your payment history. This is different from the credit reports that lenders use to determine your loan qualifications, which include household income data.

The good news is that having your credit pulled for a car insurance quote does not affect your credit score.

Car insurance rates by credit rating
Company Average annual rate: poor credit Average annual rate: good credit Price difference: good vs. poor credit
Allstate $5,924 $3,633 -39%
American Family $2,529 $1,474 -42%
Farmers $4,396 $2,620 -40%
GEICO $3,706 $1,995 -46%
Nationwide $2,099 $1,385 -34%
Progressive $4,472 $2,274 -49%
State Farm $4,146 $1,777 -57%
Travelers $3,551 $2,453 -31%
USAA $2,214 $1,444 -35%
Average $3,770 $2,124 -44%
Rates are for full-coverage car insurance for a 35-year-old male with a good driving record.

How to compare car insurance quotes

Whether you shop for car insurance online, by phone or in person, the process for comparing quotes is similar for each channel or combination of channels.

The biggest advantage of shopping for insurance online is that you can typically request and compare quotes 24/7. However, online insurance sites often connect you with live agents, who may follow up with you by phone, email or text during business hours.

Considering the amount of money a car accident or theft could cost you, you don’t want to rush through the process of purchasing car insurance. However, with just a little preparation, it won’t take too long to find the right coverage at the best price.

1. Get your documents ready

Your driver’s license and the declaration page for your current car insurance policy, if you have one, are the two most important documents to gather when you begin shopping for car insurance.

In addition to containing vital details about your current car insurance policy, your declaration page also contains your car’s vehicle identification number (VIN). If you can’t find your declaration page, dig out your vehicle registration form or any other document containing your VIN.

To get an accurate car insurance quote, you typically need to provide the following information to the insurance company:

  • Your legal name, address, marital status and date of birth (DOB)
  • The legal name and DOB of others in your household
  • The VIN for the cars you need to include on your policy
  • Your driver’s license number
  • Details about any recent traffic violations or accidents, including the date, type of incident and whether you received a citation
  • Your bank account or payment card data, for when you’re ready to purchase

If you’re seeking a quote for a car you plan to buy, the vehicle’s year, make and model typically suffices, assuming the car does not have a salvage or rebuilt title.

You should also be prepared to provide documentation needed for any discounts you may qualify to receive.

For example, if you’re seeking a good-student discount for your teen driver, you should at least know your child’s grade-point average. After you purchase your policy, you typically get a few days or longer to submit documents that confirm your eligibility for any discounts you receive.

2. Consider your coverage

Giving some consideration to the amount of car insurance coverage you need before you begin comparing quotes generally makes shopping easier.

An insurance company won’t sell you a policy that does not meet your state’s minimum car insurance requirements. However, a minimum-coverage policy may not meet all your insurance needs.

Here are some of the most common reasons to consider adding optional insurance coverages to your policy or choosing coverage limits that exceed your state’s minimum requirements:

  • If you have a car loan, or plan to get one, your lender is likely to require you to carry collision coverage and comprehensive coverage, which cover damage to the car and are also required for leases.
  • If you are upside down in your financing, you may need guaranteed insurance protection (GAP) insurance, which covers the difference between your car’s value and your loan balance.
  • If you have a high net worth or earn a high salary, you may need liability limits that exceed your state’s minimum requirements.
  • If you don’t have health insurance, or your health insurance only provides limited coverage for emergency medical treatment, consider adding uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, medical payments and/or personal injury protection to your policy. In some states, one or more of these coverages are required by law.

Your current auto policy’s declarations page shows your current coverages and limits. If you’re happy with your policy as is, you can request quotes with similar amounts.

3. Compare car insurance quotes

As you compare car insurance quotes, make sure the coverages and limits match. If one quote shows a dramatically lower rate than the others, make sure it does not contain dramatically less coverage.

Also, before you fall in love with a particular proposal, make sure the information shown in the quote about you and your vehicle is accurate.

  • Is your name spelled properly?
  • Does the quote show your current home address?
  • Is the data about your vehicle, including its year, make, model and VIN, correct?
  • Does the proposal show all the discounts you are eligible to receive?

If these or other details are listed inaccurately, contact the insurance company to correct them.

A few more tips for comparing car insurance quotes

Here are a few more things to consider as you shop for car insurance and compare quotes:

  • If you’re working with live agents, as opposed to using an automated system, consider sharing your current declaration page or a quote you like with multiple agents. This can shave some time off the process.
  • If you need collision and comprehensive coverage, choosing the highest deductibles you can afford, or your lender allows, can help you save money on your premium.
  • If your car does not have a very high market value, you may be better off removing the collision and comprehensive coverage to save money.

Also, don’t be shy about asking for discounts and having your insurance agents re-run quotes with different coverages, limits and deductibles. Ultimately, it’s up to the insurance companies to serve you, and not vice versa. You are well within your rights to make them compete for your business.

Frequently asked questions

Comparing auto insurance rates online is a simple, three-step process.

  1. Provide basic details about you, your vehicle and household.
  2. Connect with the insurance company or local agents to confirm your information and receive quotes.
  3. Select the proposal that provides the best coverage and rate.

Some car insurance companies have fully automated platforms that offer quotes and issue policies 24/7. Others have a licensed agent respond to your query during business hours. QuoteWizard shares your information with insurance agents over our secure network. All quotes are free and non-binding.

Absolutely. Insurers that offer auto, home and renters usually have a bundle option where you can apply for multiple coverages. In fact, many companies offer generous discounts for bundling. Obtaining multiple policies from the same insurer also often makes it easier to keep track of your claims and bills.

With QuoteWizard, you can obtain quotes from multiple companies by filling out a single form that typically only takes about five minutes to complete. The insurance agents who receive your quote request may reach out to you for a few additional details. After you decide on a quote to purchase, plan on needing another 15 to 20 minutes to confirm your coverage details, make your initial payment and activate your policy.

When comparing auto insurance rates, it’s important to make sure each quote you review contains the same coverages, limits and deductibles. These should each be clearly identified in your quotes. While price is important, it’s also important to make sure you have enough coverage.

Your state’s minimum car insurance requirements are a good starting point for deciding how much car insurance coverage to get, but most people need more. Your liability limits should match or exceed your net worth. Collision and comprehensive coverage are required for car loans and leases and are worth having for wholly owned cars worth a few thousand dollars or more. Uninsured motorist and personal injury protection are required in some states. Both are worth considering where optional, because they cover injuries to you and your passengers, including expenses health insurance may not cover.

Online car insurance quotes allow you to receive non-guaranteed rate estimates through your digital device. Although online car insurance platforms vary by provider, they all generally require you to provide details about yourself, your vehicle and household. Insurance companies combine this information with details they pull from credit and insurance industry databases to determine your rate, subject to verification. Insurance inquiries typically do not affect your credit score.

As an online insurance marketplace, QuoteWizard makes money by connecting insurance shoppers to insurance agents serving your community. Our platform enables you to receive three to four quotes with a single secure form. Participating agents pay us a fee for delivering the information they need to prepare a quote for you.

Insurance companies often include gender among the factors they use to determine your auto insurance rate, along with your age, ZIP code, driving record, credit, vehicle and others. Our research shows that 18-year-old women are charged less for car insurance than their male counterparts, while 35-year-old women are charged more. Some states, including California, Pennsylvania and North Carolina, ban the use of gender as a car insurance rate factor.

Methodology

Rates shown in this analysis are based on non-binding quotes for full-coverage car insurance obtained from Quadrant Information Services.

Unless otherwise noted, the typical driver is a 35-year-old male who drives a 2014 Honda LX for an average of 13,500 miles a year.

Full-coverage car insurance includes the following coverages, limits and deductibles:

  • Bodily injury liability: $100,000 per person/$300,000 per year
  • Property damage liability: $100,000
  • Collision: $500 deductible
  • Comprehensive: $500 deductible
  • In states where uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage and personal injury protection are required, the minimum limits required by law are included in the quoted policy.

Prior incidents include the following types of accidents or violations:

  • An at-fault accident resulting in $2,000 or more in property damage
  • A conviction of DUI for driving with blood alcohol content of 0.08% or greater
  • A speeding ticket for exceeding the speed limit by an unspecified amount

Price comparisons are based on an analysis of rates available from the largest insurance companies in each state and Washington D.C., with the following exceptions:

  • Gender-based price comparisons are based on rates available from the 10 largest insurance companies in the nation, excluding Liberty Mutual, which does not disclose its rates to Quadrant Information Systems.
  • Credit-score comparisons are based on average rates available from the largest car insurance companies in Florida, Illinois, New York, Ohio and Texas.

Learn more about auto insurance