Compare Car Insurance Quotes

Why Minimum Liability Car Insurance is Not Enough

Your state's legal liability car insurance minimums aren't likely to offer you, your loved ones, or the other drivers on the road much protection.

car accident and tow truck

When you buy a car, it can be tempting to obtain a policy with the minimum amount of auto insurance coverage that's legally required in your state.

But these "legal minimums" aren't going to sufficiently protect most people if they cause a car accident.

Don't believe it? Consider the following stories, each of which are highly possible regardless of your driving history or how long you've been driving. And each illustrates just how inadequate sticking to your state's minimum car-insurance requirements can be.

  • Let's say you live in one of the 30 or so states that doesn't require uninsured motorist or underinsured motorist coverage. While driving home from the grocery store, you're rear-ended by someone who lacks car insurance. You, on the other hand, have the required amount of liability coverage, but that's it. You dropped your collision coverage after you paid off your vehicle a couple of years ago. And you've never really seen the benefit of buying uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. As a result of this accident, your car is severely damaged and you have a nasty case of whiplash. But what if the driver who caused the crash has few assets and no car insurance? You'd be on your own to pay your medical bills and fix or replace your wrecked car.
  • Finally, imagine you live in a city like Dallas, which regularly experiences severe thunderstorms. Also imagine, that for whatever reason you only carry the minimum car insurance legally required of Texas drivers. Now imagine that a thunderstorm appears one day and pounds your precious Toyota Prius with hail the size of golf balls. Because you only have insurance that covers bodily injury liability and property damage liability--as opposed to comprehensive coverage, you have to pay for the repairs out of your own pocket.

You can find good, affordable coverage if you shop around. Compare quotes from different companies to get the lowest auto insurance rates.

Get to Know the Required Kinds of Liability Coverage

As suggested in the stories above, drivers in the United States aren't required to carry a whole lot of car insurance.

Every state but New Hampshire requires that its citizens own liability coverage. But that coverage often isn't enough to protect you in an accident.

That's easy to see when you consider what the required types of liability insurance actually cover:

Bodily Injury Liability (BIL). Surprisingly, perhaps, this form of coverage doesn't protect you or your vehicle. Instead, its purpose is to protect you if you--or a family member who lives with you, or a person using your car with your consent--cause an accident and injure other people as a result of it. Specifically, it protects you from any claims those folks may bring against you that are related to medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and the like.

You'll usually see this kind of coverage into two different categories: individual and total. The first category deals with the maximum your insurance company will pay for one person injured in a car accident. The second is the maximum amount your insurance provider will pay for every person injured in an accident.

A few states, like Florida, only require drivers to have $10,000 or $15,000 worth of individual bodily injury liability coverage, while others, like Alaska and Maine, require drivers to have $50,000. The low end for total bodily injury liability coverage, on the other hand, is $20,000, while the high end is $100,000—with most state minimums falling somewhere in the middle.

If some of these amounts seem adequate at first glance, consider how much medical and legal costs have skyrocketed in recent years. In that light, how far do you think, say, $10,000 of individual bodily injury liability coverage will take you if you're involved in an accident that severely injures a couple of other people? (The most likely answer: not very far.)

Property Damage Liability (PDL). This type of coverage pays for any damage you cause to the property of others due to an accident.

States like California, Massachusetts, and New Jersey only require motorists to buy $5,000 worth of property damage liability coverage. But a number of other states, Georgia and Ohio are just two examples, require at least $25,000.

Don't Forget About Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Coverage

Quite a few states also mandate that people buy uninsured motorist or underinsured motorist coverage if they want to legally hit the road.

Here's what those forms of coverage offer in terms of driver protections:

Uninsured Motorist. This type of coverage protects you or any occupants of your car if they're injured due by an uninsured driver. This coverage also protects you from hit-and-runs.

It'll also come to your aid if you or a member of your family are injured by an uninsured driver. You're also covered in hit-and-run incident as a pedestrian.

The amounts of uninsured motorist coverage that are required vary widely between the 20 or so states that mandate it.

Underinsured Motorist. This type of coverage protects you and your passengers in an accident and the at-fault driver doesn't have enough insurance to cover your medical bills. (Basically, it picks up the difference between that driver's bodily injury liability coverage limit and your underinsured motorist coverage limit.)

Only 13 states currently require drivers to purchase this kind of coverage, and the minimums related to those requirements differ from state to state.

This should be enough to convince you to consider buying both uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. if not, try this: the Insurance Research Council reported 12.6 percent of US drivers were uninsured in 2014. That’s one out of every eight drivers!

The bottom line is this: You cannot assume that because your car insurance policy is adequate just because it meets the legal minimum requirements in your state. A driver can have an insurance policy that meets their state’s minimum legal requirements, but will subject them to major financial difficulties if they are in a serious accident.

Minimum Liability Car Insurance Levels by State

Alabama 25/50/25
Alaska 50/100/25
Arizona 15/30/10
Arkansas 25/50/25
California 15/30/5
Colorado 25/50/15
Connecticut 20/40/10
Delaware 15/30/10
District of Columbia 25/50/10
Florida 10/20/10
Georgia 25/50/25
Hawaii 20/40/10
Idaho 25/50/15
Illinois 25/50/20
Indiana 25/50/10
Iowa 20/40/15
Kansas 25/50/10
Kentucky 25/50/10
Louisiana 10/20/10
Maine 50/100/25
Maryland 20/40/15
Massachusetts 20/40/5
Michigan 20/40/10
Minnesota 30/60/10
Mississippi 25/50/25
Missouri 25/50/10
Montana 25/50/10
Nebraska 25/50/25
Nevada 15/30/10
New Hampshire 25/50/25
New Jersey 15/30/5
New Mexico 25/50/10
New York 25/50/10
North Carolina 30/60/25
North Dakota 25/50/25
Ohio 25/50/25
Oklahoma 25/50/25
Oregon 25/50/10
Pennsylvania 15/30/5
Rhode Island 25/50/25
South Carolina 25/50/25
South Dakota 25/50/25
Tennessee 25/50/15
Texas 25/50/25
Utah 25/65/15
Vermont 25/50/10
Virginia 25/50/20
Washington 25/50/10
West Virginia 20/40/10
Wisconsin 25/50/10
Wyoming 25/50/20

Note: the first number in the table above refers to the bodily injury liability (BIL) limits for one person injured in an accident. This means the minimum amount of this type of coverage that's required in Alabama, for example, is $25,000. The second number refers to BIL limits for all people injured in an accident. The third number refers to property damage liability (PDL) coverage minimums in thousands of dollars.

Minimum Liability Car Insurance Q & A

Q: What is the minimum required insurance coverage for a financed vehicle?

A: The legally required minimum insurance coverage for a financed vehicle is the same as any other vehicle in a given state. However, the company financing the vehicle will require you to obtain comprehensive and collision coverage in addition to whatever coverage is required by law. Collision coverage is fairly self-explanatory. Comprehensive coverage protects a vehicle from a variety of hazards, such as:

  • theft
  • vandalism
  • hitting an animal
  • fire
  • flood
  • damage from severe weather or natural disasters
  • damage from falling objects
  • glass damage

Q:  How much car insurance coverage is enough?

A: This is a difficult question to answer because it depends on a lot of factors like:

  • where you live
  • what kind of vehicle you have
  • how much you drive

Ideally you should have liability limits of $100,000/$300,000. You should discuss your situation with a licensed insurance professional to make sure that you have adequate coverage.

Q:  Why is it that so many states haven’t updated their minimum insurance coverage requirements in decades?

A: Raising the minimum coverage requirements would mean forcing many drivers to pay more for their car insurance. This would be very politically unpopular. LLC has made every effort to ensure that the information on this site is correct, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of inaccuracies, errors, or omissions. All content and services provided on or through this site are provided "as is" and "as available" for use. LLC makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, as to the operation of this site or to the information, content, materials, or products included on this site. You expressly agree that your use of this site is at your sole risk.