Best Home Insurance Rates In Ohio

On average, your neighbors pay $68 a month.

See Your Rates

Compare Homeowners Insurance In Ohio

Monday, December 30 2019 By Aaron Besson

Homeowners insurance in Ohio costs an average of $871 a year, according to our research. This is $344 below the national average of $1,215. To help you find the best homeowners insurance rate and get the coverage that's right for you, we studied Ohio's homeowners insurance market in-depth to compare rates, policy offerings and customer satisfaction. Here's what we found:

How much does homeowners insurance cost in Ohio?

Homeowners insurance rates in Ohio have increased fairly slowly over the last few years. Ohio homeowners currently pay an average of $871 a year for insurance, or about $73 a month. As you can see, the rate of increase between 2016 and today is less than the increase between 2016 and 2015.

Average cost of home insurance in Ohio
  Today 2016 2015
Ohio annual average $871 $850 $819
Ohio price per month $73 $71 $68
U.S. annual average $1,215 $1,192 $1,173
U.S. cost per month $101 $99 $98
Note: Average rates for today are based on non-binding estimates provided by Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary. Data from 2015-2016 sourced from NAIC.

Homeowners insurance rates may vary between providers. We recommend that you compare rates before you buy homeowners insurance. Below, you will find out how rates from the biggest companies in Ohio compare.

Average yearly cost of homeowners insurance in Ohio

Average rates of home insurance in Ohio

average cost of homeowners insurance companies in pennsylvania

Best homeowners insurance companies in Ohio

Allstate, Farmers, State Farm and Westfield rise to the top as our choices for the best homeowners insurance companies in Ohio. Here's why.

Allstate: lowest rates

Allstate homeowners insurance policyholders in Ohio pay an average of $752 yearly. This is almost 14% less than the average homeowners insurance in the state of $871.

J.D. Power awarded Allstate three out of five stars for claims service and settlement, as well as overall customer service satisfaction. Furthermore, Allstate owns almost 11% of the homeowners insurance market in Ohio, second only to State Farm.

In regards to Allstate's financial strength, A.M. Best gave the company an A+ for financial backing. S&P Global gave Allstate an A- rating and Moody's Investor Services awarded the insurer an Aa3 rating for financial backing strength. This shows an excellent balance between providing low rates and a strong capability to back claims.

Farmers: runner-up for lowest premiums

Although Allstate has the cheapest rates in Ohio, according to our research, Farmers isn't far behind, with an average premium of $778. And they're still well below the average rate in Ohio.

On top of cheap rates, Farmers offers some potential money-saving benefits. For instance, they won't raise your homeowners insurance rate on a claim if you are claim-free for five years or more. You can also earn $50 a year towards your deductible every year your policy is active.

Farmers received three out of five stars for customer satisfaction in J.D. Power's 2019 homeowners insurance study and 0.16 in the NAIC Complaint Index. The index measures the number of complaints an insurer receives compared to its size. The national complaint index is always 1.00, and a lower index value means better performance. This combination of low price, discounts and few complaints gives Farmers a strong footing in Ohio.

State Farm: most popular

State Farm, the biggest homeowners insurer in Ohio, has 20.9% of the market in the state, almost twice the market share of the second-highest, Allstate. Additionally, NAIC gave State Farm 0.2 on its complaint index, the lowest rating of the companies we studied in Ohio.

State Farm's popularity with Ohio homeowners insurance policyholders is further reflected in J.D. Power's 2019 U.S. homeowners insurance study, in which it received four out of five stars for customer satisfaction.

With an average homeowners insurance premium of $881 a year, State Farm is slightly above the state average. However, it offers many discounts to help offset the cost. If you bundle auto or life insurance policies with your homeowners policy, you can save a fair amount on both premiums. Also, if you use impact-resistant materials on your roof (not a bad idea, given Ohio's extreme weather patterns) you can get a discount.

Auto-Owners: best claims record

Auto-Owners is Ohio's standout homeowners insurance company for best claims services. The insurer received four out of five stars from J.D. Power in its 2019 customer satisfaction study. Auto-Owners takes pride in its "No Problem" claims service plan.

Auto-Owners' claims service department is on hand on weeknights, weekends and holidays to help with your claim 24/7, 365 days of the year. It also has an online claims center where you can track your claim activity and get updates any time. Due to Ohio's trends of tornadoes and floods, Auto-Owners is prepared with Mobile Response Vehicles and storm teams to get to you in order to quickly expedite your claim after a catastrophe.

Biggest homeowners insurance companies in Ohio

Here's a breakdown of the homeowners insurance market in Ohio:

Home insurance companies in Pennsylvania at a glance
Company Market share 2019 J.D. Power overall satisfaction rating NAIC Complaint Index (lower is better)
State Farm 20.9% 4/5 0.20
Allstate 10.9% 3/5 0.29
Nationwide 7.3% 2/5 0.24
Grange 5.6% - 0.37
Westfield 3.9% - 0.62
Auto-Owners 3.1% 4/5 0.21
Farmers 2.8% 3/5 0.41
Note: Average rates are based on non-binding estimates provided by Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary.

To see how these insurers rank nationally, see our best home insurance companies as listed on our site.

Homeowners insurance rates in Ohio by city

Homeowners insurance premiums in Ohio average out within a $300 range. Mentor, Ohio, has the lowest premiums, with average homeowners insurance rates around $714. Dayton, Ohio, has the highest rates, with an average premium of $954.

Average yearly homeowners insurance premium by city
City Average annual homeowners insurance cost

Akron

$816

Beavercreek

$890

Canton

$823

Cincinnati

$851

Cleveland

$848

Columbus

$878

Cuyahoga

$778

Dayton

$954

Dublin

$786

Elyria

$784

Euclid

$813

Fairfield

$921

Hamilton

$925

Kettering

$901

Lakewood

$779

Lorain

$778

Mansfield

$811

Mentor

$714

Middletown

$935

Newark

$821

Parma

$767

Springfield

$850

Strongsville

$761

Toledo

$903

Youngstown

$842
Note: Average rates are based on non-binding estimates provided by Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary.

Homeowners insurance rates in Ohio by county

Here's how homeowners insurance rates compare across counties in Ohio:

Average yearly homeowners insurance premium by county
County Average annual homeowners insurance cost

Adams

$1,124

Allen

$880

Ashland

$801

Ashtabula

$785

Athens

$955

Auglaize

$869

Belmont

$818

Brown

$995

Butler

$919

Carroll

$835

Champaign

$895

Clark

$845

Clemont

$899

Clinton

$919

Columbiana

$828

Coshocton

$865

Crawford

$827

Cuyahoga

$802

Darke

$871

Defiance

$890

Delaware

$840

Erie

$801

Fairfield

$904

Fayette

$952

Franklin

$856

Fulton

$893

Gallia

$1,095

Geauga

$713

Greene

$907

Guernsey

$863

Hamilton

$847

Hancock

$902

Hardin

$897

Harrison

$853

Henry

$886

Highland

$971

Hocking

$972

Holmes

$795

Huron

$820

Jackson

$1,146

Jefferson

$838

Knox

$823

Lake

$728

Lawrence

$1,040

Licking

$839

Logan

$865

Lorain

$772

Lucas

$878

Madison

$894

Mahoning

$840

Marion

$879

Medina

$763

Meigs

$1,008

Mercer

$904

Miami

$827

Monroe

$900

Montgomery

$936

Morgan

883

Morrow

$844

Muskingum

$880

Noble

$872

Ottawa

$874

Paulding

$892

Perry

$924

Pickaway

$921

Pike

$1,146

Portage

$810

Preble

$908

Putnam

$911

Richland

$812

Ross

$1,095

Sandusky

$852

Scioto

$1,125

Seneca

$852

Shelby

$866

Stark

$821

Summit

$799

Trumbull

$813

Tuscarawas

$848

Union

$868

Van Wert

$926

Vinton

$1,047

Warren

$941

Washington

$889

Wayne

$788

Williams

$826

Wood

$877

Wyandot

$857
Note: Average rates are based on non-binding estimates provided by Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary.

Homeowners insurance perils in Ohio

Weather trends may affect homeowners insurance rates in Ohio. Here are some of the bigger weather risks that Ohio homeowners have to deal with:

Snowfall

Northern Ohio tends to get more extreme snowfall than the southern part of the state. Portsmouth, Ohio, may only see an average of 9.5 inches of snow per year. On the other end of the spectrum, Cleveland can see an average of 68 inches of snow a year.

Heavy snows are a serious danger to your roof. If too much snow accumulates on your roof, the weight can cause it to collapse. This type of damage is usually covered by homeowners insurance, but it is in your best interest to prevent a claim in the first place. A hole in your roof in the winter is not something you want to try to live with for any amount of time.

Another danger snowfall presents for Ohio homeowners is accumulated ice. If the temperature drops enough to freeze, ice can turn walkways around your house into danger zones. If someone slips and falls on your property because of ice, you could find yourself responsible for a hospital stay or involved in a lawsuit if they sue.

Homeowners insurance provides liability coverage to deal with these instances. It can pay medical bills or cover legal fees and award payouts resulting from a lawsuit due to an accident on your property. Much like taking care of snow on your roof, prevention is the key with liability issues due to ice on your premises. Keep your sidewalks shoveled and salted to help avoid making a claim in the first place.

Tornadoes

According to the National Weather Service, Ohio had 18 tornadoes in 2018. The damage a tornado can do to a home can easily run into hundreds of thousands of dollars, or even a total loss.

Most homeowners insurance policies cover tornado damage. A good way to help reduce the potential damage a tornado can do to your home is to install storm windows; reinforce the roof and remove freestanding items like lawn chairs, potted plants and other yard items that can become projectiles during a tornado.

Flood

In 2018, the Ohio River rose to over 60 feet, making it the worst flood Cincinnati had seen since 1997, when it rose to almost 65 feet, causing more than $155 million in damages to Southern Ohio alone.

Flood damage is not typically covered by homeowners insurance. However, flood insurance is available through FEMA's National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). Many Ohio homeowners insurance providers and some independent agents take part in the NFIP and can help protect your home against flood.

Depending on what kind of flood zone your home is in, your mortgage provider may require you to have flood insurance. You can check the FEMA flood zone map to see what kind of risk your home may face.

Methodology

We compiled quotes for every ZIP code in Ohio from seven of the top insurers. We based our analysis on Allstate, Auto-Owners, Farmers, Grange Mutual, Nationwide, State Farm and Westfield policy data. Quotes were for a home worth $161,544, built in 1969 and owned by a 58-year-old. These are the median home value, construction date and homeowner age in Ohio.

We picked the insurers for our study using S&P Global Market Intelligence, which ensures results as localized to Ohio as possible. The largest subsidiary in Ohio of every insurer was taken as a representative for the company.

QuoteWizard.com LLC has made every effort to ensure that the information on this site is correct, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of inaccuracies, errors, or omissions. All content and services provided on or through this site are provided "as is" and "as available" for use. QuoteWizard.com LLC makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, as to the operation of this site or to the information, content, materials, or products included on this site. You expressly agree that your use of this site is at your sole risk.