Compare Car Insurance Quotes

How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident?

Car accidents can almost double your premiums. Shop around to minimize your insurance going up and even save hundreds.

car accident

According to our research, depending on the type of accident or violation, your car insurance premium can increase anywhere from 4% to 95% on average. Any rate increase should happen at the time of your car insurance policy renewal, making it the critical time to shop around for cheaper quotes. The amount your insurance premium goes up after an accident depends on many factors, including the total damage caused, the type of damage, your policy specifics and more.

To mitigate how much your car insurance goes up after an accident, you need to shop around with other auto insurance companies. Each insurer accounts for accidents differently when calculating your premium, meaning certain insurers may provide more favorable rates. And if your car insurance does go up after an accident, remember the increase is only temporary. Car accidents typically only stay on your record for three to five years.

In this article we will touch on…

How much does insurance increase after an accident?

Across our research sample, we found that car insurance may increase anywhere from 3% to 94% after an accident or a speeding ticket. On average, not at-fault accidents result in the lowest premium increase, followed by a speeding ticket, then property damage. Bodily injury accidents make your insurance rates go up the most.

Type of accident or violation Average percent increase after an accident or speeding ticket
One not at-fault accident 3%
One speeding ticket 18%
One speeding ticket with $3,000 in property damage costs 44%
One accident with $3,000 in bodily injury costs 55%
Two accidents with $3,000 in bodily injury costs 81%
Two accidents with $3,000 in bodily injury costs each 95%
Note: Average rate increases are based on non-binding estimates provided by Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary.1

Property damage can involve damaging someone’s mailbox, a public lamp or any other property. Bodily injury can involve things such as medical costs and foregone wages due to an accident-related injury. A standard auto insurance policy’s liability coverage includes both of these forms of coverage if you cause an accident.

If you’re at fault in an accident, your rates will likely increase, but the amount will vary based on your specifics, including your coverage, driving history, whether the accident was minor or major, and any other pertinent details. Rate increases typically take place when your policy is up for renewal. There is no set percentage that your insurance rates go up after an at-fault accident, but we found that in specific cases:

  • Some car insurance policies do not increase auto premiums even after two insurance claims after accidents. In New York, for example, we found that State Farm, Allstate, USAA, and Erie all had policies that had the same pricing for a driver with no accidents, one at-fault accident, and two at-fault accidents.
  • Some companies have modest price increases after the first at-fault accident, but more than double your premiums after a second one. In one case, our research found that a company increased premiums by around 45% after one at-fault accident, but increased rates by 174% from the original rate after two accidents.
  • By switching providers after an accident, you can potentially get a cheaper rate than the one you had before your accident. We found that in one example, by switching from a GEICO policy in Texas to Allstate after one at-fault accident with property damage, our sample driver could save a few hundred dollars annually. Rates vary greatly per individual, so you need to make sure to shop around to find quotes specific for you.

Even if you had chosen the cheapest quote you found at the time of your initial auto insurance purchase, another insurance company may offer you a significantly cheaper quote after an accident. If your rates go up, make sure to shop around for insurance quotes. Doing so can keep your insurance rates low and affordable.

Insurance rates increase after a no-fault accident

We found that one no-fault accident makes your insurance rates go up by 3% annually, on average. Increases in premiums might be due to the fact that in general, filing claims goes on your claims record and can lead to higher premiums with your insurance company.

In some cases, however, your insurance premiums might not go up at all after an accident when you’re not at fault. Some states (like California and Oklahoma) don’t raise premiums after a no-fault accident. And some companies will not increase your premiums if you’ve been a good driver and it is a minor accident.

car insurance premiums after one not at fault accident

Across these five states, we see there is an average $75 increase in annual premiums after being found not at-fault in an accident. Remember, even in states like Illinois, where there is a higher-than-average increase in premiums, some insurers do not increase your auto insurance costs after a not at-fault accident. Make sure to gather quotes to ensure you’re getting the best rates.

Insurance price increase after one at-fault accident, property damage only

Any accident you cause resulting in property damage will increase your insurance premiums by 44% on average, according to our research. Accidents that involve property damage typically lead to lower premium increases than those that involve bodily injury.

car insurance premiums after one at fault accident

Insurance price increase after two at-fault accidents, property damage only

Being found at fault in two accidents — even if they only involve property damage — will lead to a significant premium increase. We found that two accidents that resulted in property damage each time translates to an 81% increase in premiums on average. This is nearly double the increase in insurance costs than if you only had one accident. Any accidents indicate to your insurer that you are a high risk driver and are more likely to cost the insurance company money, which results in higher premiums for you.

car insurance premiums after two at fault accidents

Insurance price increase after one at-fault accident with bodily injury

Accidents that involve claims for bodily injury costs are more expensive than those that have property damage only. We found that one accident with bodily injury results in over a 54% price increase on average.

car insurance premiums after one at fault bodily injury accident

Insurance price increase after two at-fault accidents with bodily injury

Causing two accidents that result in bodily injury claims leads to the highest insurance premium increases out of all other accidents and violations we tested. Drivers can expect on average for annual premiums to increase by 94%, nearly doubling rates of a comparable driver with no accidents. Although these hikes seem steep, the increase is only temporary. Usually accidents fall off your insurance record after three to five years. And shopping around might prevent significant increases in premiums.

car insurance premiums after two at fault bodily injury accidents

Does a speeding ticket increase insurance?

Car accidents aren’t the only incidents that can affect your insurance premiums. We found that on average, one speeding ticket increases your annual auto insurance premium by 17%.

car insurance premiums after one speeding ticket

The increase in your premium after a speeding ticket depends on a few factors, including:

  • How many miles per hour above the speed limit you were driving
  • How many tickets you have
  • If you had a good driver discount (which you can lose with even a ticket)

Your rate will only increase if your car insurance company knows you got a ticket for speeding (or other violations). Your auto insurer needs to pay to access these records, so the frequency at which they check will vary based on how risky of a driver you are. For a generally good driver, your rates will most likely only increase at the time of renewal. At that point, make sure to shop around for quotes to see if you can get cheaper rates.

Accident forgiveness isn’t free, but could be worth it

You’ve heard and seen that accidents aren’t cheap — we found that in some cases, accidents can increase your premiums more than 94%. So you might be interested in accident forgiveness to avoid that dreaded premium hike. In reality, however, accident forgiveness might not lead to cheaper rates after all if you’re a very safe driver.

Accident forgiveness is an additional coverage offered by many auto insurers. For some insurers, you can purchase it for a fee if you have a clean driving record. These fees vary widely, but are typically around 3% to 5% of your premium. Other insurers offer it for free after a few years of being accident free with the car insurance company. Let’s walk through an example of how much accident forgiveness coverage might cost you:

Let’s say your annual premium for car insurance is $2,000. To add on accident forgiveness coverage, you pay a 3% increase — so in total, you’re now paying $2,060 a year for your car insurance. Each year, you pay an extra $60 to protect your rates against an accident you might never get into. If you’re a very safe driver, accident forgiveness might not be worth it since you might never be at-fault in an accident. But if you want to err on the safe side, you could easily find the marginal annual premium increase worth it.

Your rates can still increase after being in an accident, even with accident forgiveness. You might lose your good driver discount, which can lead to even a 20% hike in annual insurance premiums. In other words, accident forgiveness does not guarantee you won’t see an increase in premiums after an accident. If you want to shop around after an accident, other companies will still consider your accident history and adjust your quotes to be more expensive than before your accident.

Filing a claim after an accident may be more expensive for you in the long run

Filing an insurance claim typically leads to an increase in auto insurance premiums. So in some cases, you might not want to file a claim in the first place.

When you should not file a claim:

  • The costs of the damage caused is less than (or slightly more than) your deductible. For example, say your car repairs are $700 and your deductible is $500. If you simply paid out of pocket rather than make a claim, you would have to pay $200 more. This could prevent a hike in your car insurance premium, which could be much cheaper in the long run. If it’s a minor accident, you might not want to file a claim.

When you should consider filing a claim:

  • The damages you sustained or caused are very costly. You cannot afford to pay for them out of pocket, and the costs are significantly greater than any applicable deductibles.

If you already filed a claim but are worried about increasing insurance premiums, you can cancel an insurance claim. To cancel your insurance claim, contact your insurance agent.

How long does an accident stay on your insurance?

An accident claim stays on your insurance record for three to five years. So if you’re hit with higher premiums after an accident, you may face those higher rates for three to five years. With some companies, if you keep a clean driving record during that time, your insurance premiums can decrease over time at each point of renewal. For other companies, your premium will only begin to decrease after the accident is not on your insurance record.

In some states, an accident can only stay on your insurance record for three years. But after those three years, you could be on probation for three more years. Any violations or accidents may lead to steep insurance cost increases.

Within these years, you need to make sure to shop around for insurance. Different insurance companies may offer different rates after you’ve been in an accident.

How to find cheaper car insurance after an accident

The first step to finding the lowest rates after an accident is to shop around for quotes. There’s even a chance you can end up with a lower premium than you had before your accident by switching insurers. You can’t predict how much your premiums will increase with your current provider, but you can take some critical steps to keep your rates low, especially if you’re a high risk driver.

In general:

  1. Shop around for quotes after a car accident to potentially save hundreds of dollars.
  2. Increase your deductible to lower your premium.
  3. Enroll in a safe driving course.

Let’s say you caused an accident and your car is totaled, but you still need to keep your car insurance. Let’s walk through how to get cheap car insurance in this case:

If your car is totaled/unusable:

  1. Wait for your insurance company to deem your car a total loss.
  2. Minimize your auto insurance coverage to the state minimum requirements to save on your premium.
  3. Opt out of any optional coverages such as collision or personal injury protection, since you won’t be driving your car.
  4. Increase your deductible, or the amount you pay out of pocket, on your liability coverage to decrease your insurance premium costs.
  5. If you’re looking to drive again, think about switching car insurance after your accident. Start shopping around for new rates and have a policy you want in mind for when you find out if your car is a total loss.

Methodology

1For all of the rates we gathered, our base driver profile was a 30-year-old single man with a clean driving history. The driver owns a 2014 Honda Accord and selects the minimum liability coverage required auto policy. Annually, the driver drives his vehicle 15,000 miles.

We sampled all ZIP codes in five of the most populated states: California, New York, Texas, Illinois and Pennsylvania. Average rates are based on non-binding estimates provided by Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary.

We analyzed six different scenarios:

  • Our base driver is involved in, but is not at fault for, one accident.
  • Our base driver causes one at-fault accident with $3,000 in property damage.
  • Our base driver causes two at-fault accidents with $3,000 in property damage each accident.
  • Our base driver causes one at-fault accident with $3,000 in bodily injury.
  • Our base driver causes two at-fault accidents with $3,000 in bodily injury each accident.
  • Our base driver is found speeding six to 10 miles per hour above the speed limit.

QuoteWizard.com LLC has made every effort to ensure that the information on this site is correct, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of inaccuracies, errors, or omissions. All content and services provided on or through this site are provided "as is" and "as available" for use. QuoteWizard.com LLC makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, as to the operation of this site or to the information, content, materials, or products included on this site. You expressly agree that your use of this site is at your sole risk.