Compare Health Insurance Plans

The Best Medicare Supplement Companies

Here are 10 of the best Medicare supplement insurance companies to consider while shopping for a Medigap plan.

two seniors looking at computer screen

Shopping for Medicare supplement insurance can be tough. For starters, there are 10 Medicare supplement plan types to choose from at the moment. Also, a ton of companies currently sell these policies, which some call MedSup or Medigap.

To help you find the best Medigap plan for your situation, here are 10 top Medicare supplement insurance companies you should consider while shopping for MedSup coverage.

Top 10 Medicare supplement insurance companies

We considered several factors to come up with this list of best Medicare supplement insurance companies, including:

  • Company size and financial strength
  • How long the company has been around
  • The number of Medigap plans it sells
  • Where it sells them (in which states)

Aetna: Best for stability

If you’re looking for a Medicare supplement provider that has been around for a long time and is likely to stick around for many years to come, look no further than Aetna. Aetna was founded in 1853 — that means it’s been in business for more than 160 years.

Other reasons to consider Aetna for Medigap:

  • It sells six Medigap plans — F, G, K, L, M and N
  • It has a user-friendly online portal
  • It has an A rating for financial strength from A.M. Best

Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield: Best for discounts

Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield has you covered if you want Medigap discounts. For starters, it offers a 5% household discount in many states. It also provides discounts for annual payments and payments that use automatic withdrawal.

Other reasons to consider Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield for Medigap coverage:

  • It has an A rating from A.M. Best
  • It is licensed to sell Medicare supplement plans in 14 states

Bankers Fidelity Life: Best plan selection for a small company

This Atlanta-based insurance company sells eight different Medicare supplement plans. That’s a lot for any insurer, but it’s especially impressive for a small one.

Other reasons to look to Bankers Fidelity Life for your Medigap needs:

  • It is licensed to sell Medicare supplement plans in 46 states
  • It also sells life and cancer insurance
  • It has an A- rating from A.M. Best

Central States Indemnity of Omaha: Best rated small company

Central States Indemnity of Omaha has an A+ rating from A.M. Best. That makes it a standout among small Medicare supplement providers.

Other reasons to consider Central States Indemnity of Omaha for Medigap plans:

  • It is owned by Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
  • It is licensed to sell Medigap plans in 50 states, plus Washington D.C., Puerto Rico and Guam

Cigna: Best for couples

If you and your spouse — or someone else in your household — buys a Medigap plan from Cigna, you could earn a household premium discount of 7%.

Other reasons to consider Cigna for Medicare supplement coverage:

  • It offers enrollees a Cigna Healthy Rewards program, which can earn you even more savings
  • It’s been around since 1982
  • It has an A- rating from A.M. Best

Humana: Best coverage

Humana is licensed to sell Medigap policies in a whopping 45 states, plus Washington, D.C.

Also, it sells eight different plans: A, B, C, F, G, K, L and N. It sells the high-deductible Plan F, too. (Note: all plans aren’t available in all states.)

Other reasons to look to Humana for Medigap coverage:

  • It has been in operation for nearly 60 years
  • It offers enrollees a variety of discounts and perks
  • It has an A- rating from A.M. Best

Mutual of Omaha: Best discounts for a small company

Actually, you could argue that Mutual of Omaha offers the best Medicare supplement discount of any Medigap provider, regardless of size. Its household discount can cut your premium by 12%. As if that weren’t enough, your spouse, partner or roommate doesn’t need to be a policyholder. They just need to live with you and be over 60.

Other reasons to consider Mutual of Omaha for Medicare supplement insurance:

  • It has an A+ rating from A.M. Best
  • It first opened its doors 110 years ago

State Farm: Best all-around service

If you want options when it comes to accessing Medicare supplement agents, State Farm may be the company for you. Its agents can help you online, over the phone or even in person. That’s not something you can say about every insurer these days.

Other reasons to consider State Farm for Medigap plans:

  • It has an A++ rating from A.M. Best
  • It sells six Medicare supplement plans — A, C, D, F, G and N

UnitedHealthcare: Best for AARP members

What do you get when you combine two well-known brands like AARP and UnitedHealthcare? You get a Medicare supplement insurance provider that’s seriously difficult to ignore while shopping for a Medigap plan. This is especially true when you consider UnitedHealthcare’s Medigap plans are the only ones that carry AARP’s name and support.

Other reasons to look at UnitedHealthcare for Medigap coverage:

  • It sells eight different Medigap plans
  • It offers several premium discounts, including a 5% household discount
  • It has an A rating from A.M. Best

USAA: Best for military members and their families

USAA is known for offering the best insurance plans and products, and its Medicare supplement policies are no exception. The only caveat: you must be active military, former military, or an eligible family member to buy a Medigap plan from USAA.

Other reasons to look to USAA for your Medigap needs:

  • It has been around for nearly 100 years
  • It serves almost every state
  • It has an A++ rating from A.M. Best

Compare Medicare supplement plans

Not only do a lot of insurance companies sell Medigap plans, but they sell a lot of different Medigap plans, too.

In fact, insurers can sell up to 10 different Medigap plans. They go by letters — like Plan A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M and N.

Use the information below to compare Medigap benefits and find the best Medicare supplement plan for you.

Medigap Plan A

Medigap Plan A is the most basic Medicare supplement plan. It covers these out-of-pocket costs: your Medicare Part A coinsurance and hospital costs, your Part A hospice care coinsurance or copayment, your Medicare Part B coinsurance or copayment and the first three pints of blood you receive each year.

Medigap Plan B

Medigap Plan B covers all the same costs as Medigap Plan A, plus it covers your Medicare Part A deductible.

Medigap Plan C

Medigap Plan C covers the same costs as Medigap Plan B. It also covers the Medicare Part B deductible, skilled nursing facility care coinsurance and 80% of foreign travel emergency care.

Medigap Plan D

Medigap Plan D covers the same costs as Medigap Plan C except it doesn’t cover the Part B deductible.

Medigap Plan F

Medigap Plan F is the most popular Medigap plan. It’s also the most comprehensive. It covers all the costs mentioned so far as well as the Medicare Part B excess charge.

Medigap Plan G

Medigap Plan G covers the same costs as Medigap Plan F except for the Part B deductible.

Medigap Plan K

Medigap Plan K is similar to Medigap Plan D. Plan K differs from Plan D by only covering 50% of most costs. It also has an out-of-pocket limit of $5,560.

Medigap Plan L

Medigap Plan L is like Medigap Plan K but only covers 75% of most costs. Its out-of-pocket limit is $2,780.

Medigap Plan M

Medigap Plan M is the same as Medigap Plan D but only covers 50% of the Medicare Part A deductible.

Medigap Plan N

Medigap Plan N also is the same as Medigap Plan D but it doesn’t cover all Medicare Part B copayments.

To compare Medigap plans side by side, see our Medicare supplement plans comparison chart.

When to buy Medigap plans

You can buy a Medicare supplement plan whenever you want — as long as you’re over the age of 65 and you’re enrolled in Medicare Part A and Part B.

But when should you buy one of these policies? The best time to buy a Medigap plan is during your Medigap open enrollment period. This six-month window starts the month you’re both 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B.

During the Medigap open enrollment period, you can buy any Medicare supplement plan sold in your state, even if you have health problems. And not only that, but you can buy a plan for the same price as someone in perfect health.

After this enrollment period ends, you might pay a lot more for that same Medigap policy. And you may not be able to buy a Medigap policy at all. This is because, outside of open enrollment, insurance companies can refuse to sell Medicare supplement coverage to people based on their health or medical histories.

How to save money on Medicare supplement insurance

Medicare supplement insurance can be expensive. You could spend as much as $2,000 a year on a Medigap plan, according to HealthView Services, a maker of healthcare cost-projection software. That equals about $160 per month.

How much you pay for a Medigap plan can depend on several factors, such as:

  • The plan you buy
  • Where you buy it
  • Where you live
  • Your gender
  • If you’re a smoker or not

Also, insurance companies price Medicare supplement plans using one of three methods:

  • Companies that use the issue-age-rate method base your monthly premium on your age when you buy the plan. 
  • Insurers using the attained-age-rate method base your premium on your current age. This means it increases as you get older. 
  • And insurance companies that use the community-rated method ignore your age and charge the same premium to everyone who has the same Medigap plan.

To save money on Medigap, do one or more of the following:

  • Shop around and switch to a Medigap plan that costs less than your current one does.
  • Ask the insurance companies serving your area if they offer any discounts on these plans. Some give discounts to women, non-smokers, married people, people who pay yearly and more.
  • Move to an area where Medicare supplement plans cost less than they do where you live now.
  • Stop smoking.

Medicare supplement insurance basics

Although most people get Medicare Part A and Part B coverage from the federal government, that’s not where you buy Medicare supplement insurance.

Instead, you buy Medigap plans from private insurance companies. The plans these companies sell are standardized. This means that all Medigap Plan G policies must provide the same benefits, no matter where you buy them.

Here are some other basic details to keep in mind as you shop for a Medicare supplement plan:

  • Insurance companies can sell up to 10 Medigap plans at the moment — A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M and N.
  • People new to Medicare won’t be able to buy Medigap Plan C or F starting on January 1, 2020.
  • Don’t look for any of the letters listed above if you live in Massachusetts, Minnesota or Wisconsin. The plans sold in those states are standardized in a different way.
  • Companies that sell Medigap plans don’t have to sell all 10 of them. If they sell any, though, one must be Plan A.
  • You need to be enrolled in Original Medicare, or Medicare Parts A and B, before you can buy any MedSup policy. You can’t be enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan, however.

QuoteWizard.com LLC has made every effort to ensure that the information on this site is correct, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of inaccuracies, errors, or omissions. All content and services provided on or through this site are provided "as is" and "as available" for use. QuoteWizard.com LLC makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, as to the operation of this site or to the information, content, materials, or products included on this site. You expressly agree that your use of this site is at your sole risk.