Common Types of Car Insurance Fraud

Car insurance fraud is more common than you may think. It costs the insurance industry billions of dollars a year. Learn more about insurance fraud and what to do if you’re the victim of auto insurance fraud.

Auto Insurance Fraud Claims Folder

Auto insurance fraud is becoming a bigger issue in the US. It costs insurance companies billions of dollars every year. Learning what auto insurance fraud is and how it affects you is the first step to protecting yourself from becoming a victim.

Think insurance fraud only hurts insurers and doesn’t impact you? Think again. Insurance companies need to compensate for money lost due to fraud and raise rates for everyone – even those who haven’t committed fraud –to make up for it. And there are also types of insurance fraud that target individuals, not companies.

Types of Car Insurance Fraud

Car insurance fraud is when someone deceives an auto insurance company for financial gain. There are two types of car insurance fraud that have different implications and levels of severity. These include soft fraud and hard fraud.

Soft Insurance Fraud

Soft insurance fraud occurs when a legitimate claim is exaggerated for financial gain. It is the more minor offense of the fraud types, and it also the most common type of car insurance fraud. Soft insurance fraud can even happen unintentionally. It’s important to be completely honest in your insurance claims, or you could commit insurance fraud.

For example, if someone injures their back in a fender bender, but exaggerate their injury to gain more compensation, they are engaging in insurance fraud. Also, if a driver claims that a pre-existing medical issue is due to a recent accident, they are committing soft insurance fraud.

Hard Insurance Fraud

Hard insurance fraud is a much more serious crime than soft insurance fraud. It’s an intentionally caused insurance loss, like a collision, auto theft, or fire. These incidents are covered by insurance, and the policyholder subsequently files a claim for damages. Hard insurance fraud is sometimes done by criminal groups, who steal millions of dollars through these false claims.

One example of hard insurance fraud is a car owner staging a break in and stripping their car of valuables like wheels, seats, the radio, and more. They then file an insurance claim for the ‘stolen’ valuables to collect compensation.

Another common example of hard insurance fraud is a ‘forced’ accident, especially rear ends. A driver will pull in front of another car and brake hard. The other driver won’t have time to stop, and they’ll rear end the car. The fraudster will file a claim for the damages, and they may also claim a neck or back injury. A rear end is almost always considered the fault of the driver who hits the back of the other car, especially if there are no witnesses or video evidence. This makes it an attractive ruse.

Common Fraud Examples

You may be surprised to find out how many ways there are to commit car insurance fraud. The severity of these cases varies, and so do the consequences for insurance fraud. These are some of the most common examples of auto insurance fraud:

  • Filing several claims for a single injury or accident
  • Using fake car insurance
  • Registering a vehicle in a different state for cheaper rates
  • Providing false information while getting a quote
  • Staging a car accident
  • Submitting a claim for a medical treatment that never happened
  • Falsely reporting a car as stolen
  • Filing a claim for injuries that weren’t received during the accident
  • Purchasing a policy after an accident occurs

Penalties for Car Insurance Fraud

The justice system prosecutes auto insurance fraud. Punishments vary from state to state. Depending on the severity of the crime, it will be categorized as a misdemeanor or a felony. If you’re charged with fraud (either a misdemeanor or felony), the impact is long-term – it will go on your criminal record. That’s why it’s important to be honest when reporting claims to your insurer.

Misdemeanor Car Insurance Fraud

Most car insurance fraud convictions are for soft fraud. And soft is generally treated as a misdemeanor. If you distort your injuries for more money or file several claims for a single injury, for example, you could face a misdemeanor charge for soft fraud. This comes with legal punishments.

According to, a soft fraud conviction “can carry a fine of up to $15,000.” A misdemeanor conviction could also mean probation and even possible jail time. That jail term can’t be longer than five years and generally isn’t doled out except in extreme cases, like repeat offenders.

Felony Car Insurance Fraud

A felony charge for insurance fraud requires destruction of property. When it comes to auto insurance fraud, this usually means arson. It’s also possible if somebody is killed during a staged accident. Those examples qualify as hard fraud and will cost you more than just a fine.

The penalty for a felony insurance fraud charge is much more extreme than a misdemeanor charge. If you’re convicted for a felony, you’ll can face between five to 10 years in jail. In addition to possible jail time, you’ll probably have to pay a fine. That fine can go up all the way to $150,000, but the monetary amount and jail time vary from state to state and depending on the crime.

How Car Insurance Fraud Hurts Your Rates

Car insurance fraud doesn’t only impact insurer profits, but also your rates. That’s because insurance companies partly base policy prices on their losses. The more losses filed in your city or state, the higher your insurance prices go to compensate.

Michigan has some of the highest insurance rates in the country. In fact, Michigan drivers pay nearly 40 percent more for car insurance compared to the average American. Not coincidentally, Michigan has an extremely high rate of insurance fraud. And this high rate of fraud is the leading cause of rising auto insurance rates in the state. If you live in an area with higher-than-average rates of insurance fraud, you’ll pay for it. Your rates will be significantly higher based on auto insurance fraud in your area.

What to Do If You’re the Victim of Insurance Fraud

So, what do you do if you’re the victim of insurance fraud or if you think you’ve witnessed fraud? You should report the incident right away. Contact the police. Get in touch with your state’s Department of Insurance. Also, let your insurance company know if you think you’re the victim of fraud.

Your insurance carrier may have anti-fraud and criminal investigators that aim to prevent insurance fraud. They work to train employees to look for fraud, investigate suspicious claims, and collaborate with law enforcement to track down the source of fraud.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is insurance fraud a felony?

A: Insurance fraud can constitute a felony, yes. But that’s not always the case. It depends on whether it’s soft or hard auto insurance fraud.

Soft fraud, when a legitimate claim is exaggerated for financial gain, usually results in a misdemeanor, not a felony. Most types of insurance fraud fall under this category. In fact, it’s even possible to unintentionally commit soft fraud.

Hard fraud is when a person intentionally causes a loss to then file a claim, like a collision, theft, or fire. Hard insurance fraud results in a felony charge if there is destruction of property. That could include a staged accident where someone was killed, or arson. If you’re charged with a felony for auto insurance fraud, you could serve five to 10 years in prison.

Q: If I fake my grades for an auto insurance discount, is it considered fraud?

A: Some car insurance companies offer savings to students with good grades. In order to get this discount, you’ll have to provide an official transcript that confirms the good grades. If you, as a student driver, decide to change your grades on that transcript, you could be found guilty of insurance fraud.

It may seem like a small change for a bit of a discount, but you could be subject to the legal implications of insurance fraud. If you’re found guilty it would mean a misdemeanor charge, which can result in a fine up to $15,000, probation, and even jail time under five years.

Q: Is there a time limit to being prosecuted for car insurance fraud?

A: The statute of limitations for insurance fraud varies depending on the state the crime was committed in. For example, in Washington State there is a three-year statute of limitations for fraud. Whereas in Texas there is a five-year statute of limitations for insurance fraud. Usually, the statute of limitations for insurance fraud varies from two to seven years across the country. LLC has made every effort to ensure that the information on this site is correct, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of inaccuracies, errors, or omissions. All content and services provided on or through this site are provided "as is" and "as available" for use. LLC makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, as to the operation of this site or to the information, content, materials, or products included on this site. You expressly agree that your use of this site is at your sole risk.